Posted on

Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping

Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping Best Read || [Judith Levine] Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping Best Read || [Judith Levine] - Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping, Not Buying It My Year Without Shopping An award winning journalist traces a year during which she and her partner struggled with a pledge to avoid consumer spending practices in spite of their American conditioning an effort that had a pr

  • Title: Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping
  • Author: Judith Levine
  • ISBN: 9780743269353
  • Page: 495
  • Format: Hardcover

Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping Best Read || [Judith Levine], Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping, Judith Levine, Not Buying It My Year Without Shopping An award winning journalist traces a year during which she and her partner struggled with a pledge to avoid consumer spending practices in spite of their American conditioning an effort that had a profound impact on their careers family relationships and personal identities

Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping

Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping Best Read || [Judith Levine] Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping Best Read || [Judith Levine] - Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping, Not Buying It My Year Without Shopping An award winning journalist traces a year during which she and her partner struggled with a pledge to avoid consumer spending practices in spite of their American conditioning an effort that had a pr Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping

  • Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping Best Read || [Judith Levine]
    495Judith Levine
Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping

218 Comment Not Buying It: My Year Without Shopping

  1. I didn t buy this I got it from the library I was amazed, first of all, at how awkwardly written it is considering the author is a professional editor It s repetitive, and there is actually very little focused attention paid to any guidelines she has for what is necessary She has minimal insight and seems to have missed the point of her own book I mean, this review is not well written, either, but I m not a writer or an editor I m just a disgruntled reader.While the author does raise some good p [...]


  2. This book was awful The experiment the author poses is a worthy one go a year without shopping necessities excluded Unfortunately, the author and her husband find a way to categorize nearly EVERYTHING as a necessity, including but not limited to three cars there are only two people in their family , an addition to their SUMMER home, the New York Times and Starbucks on Sundays, gourmet food for their cat and a 12 pair of socks And that s all before page 40 Further compounding my frustration with [...]


  3. Three years after reading this, I m still pissed off about it It was educational, but not about not shopping or our consumer culture rather, it perfectly encapsulates a specific overprivileged mindset The idea is fascinating The book is also fascinating, but only in the way a trainwreck is the author announces she s only buying necessities, then decrees that everything is a necessity the New York Times Expensive haircuts Basically, she spends the year not buying new clothes or dinners out And sh [...]


  4. I actually couldn t finish this book.Sure she was funny and entertaining but it takes a certain kind of constitution to take in all the super liberal hippie bullshit she tries to sneak in under the radar Don t get me wrong, it s not like I hate super liberal hippie s, I love them But I m not about to inundate myself with all their propaganda and that was exactly what I was inviting into bed with me every night before I went to bed and it suuuuucked.Honestly, the point where she lost me was her r [...]


  5. If you were really committed to not buying anything for a full year besides the necessities , then this book would be a primer on how to not do it She remodels her house, takes vacations from not buying and proves time and time again that an exercise in frugality is common than an exercise in dicipline If your motivation is to live a life simple, Don t buy this book, either I ll give it to you, or better I won t buy any firestarter and this will be the kindling that allows me to turn my thermo [...]


  6. I requested this book through Inter Library Loan at my work and read it in a weekend It is a month by month documentation of a self employed New York author s project of abstaining from buying anything outside of the absolutely necessary for one year It was a lot human than I thought it was going to be By that, I mean that there were no black and white judgments about being a consumer For instance, her struggle with defining what is necessary involved a great examination of desire, moral judgme [...]


  7. My sister recommended this book to me because I had started to reevaluate my spending habits, and had decided to try and buck the consumerist mindset that caused me to start to slip into credit card debt.The book is written by a woman who decided that for one year, she and her husband would buy NOTHING that was not absolutely necessary No dinners out, no new clothes, no prepared foods, and so on.The book started out as an interesting description of how hard it was to make the mental switch from [...]


  8. I know, this doesn t seem like something I d choose, and of course I didn t it s a book club book When I first started it, I was enjoying it I was caught up in the start of Levine s project and thinking about how I need to watch my own shopping habit closely But as the book went on, her memoir cum journalist essay style grew wearing I liked the memoir bits enough, but then she d be like, So then I consulted such and such expert at such and such academic center and cite a bunch of statistics Plu [...]


  9. A brilliant concept squandered by perhaps the most unbelievably pretentious, self absorbed, and hypocritical author I ve ever had the misfortune of reading Disgusted by our consumeristic culture, Judith Levine and her partner decide to spend a year of not purchasing anything , beyond basic necessities Problem is, the author considers The New York Times, Starbucks, an extension on her second home, and 55 haircuts to be necessities The absurdity doesn t end there, though Ms Levine frequently likes [...]


  10. What was a promising premise, not buying non essentials for a year and critiquing consumer society, sadly turned into a lot of unjust whining by the Author Indeed, much of the book is a poor me attitude about not being able to buy things that are already a luxury many of us can not afford The most annoying part was when her and her boyfriend are trying to decide to sell one of their many cars and complaining about how hard it is As someone who choose to have zero cars, I found it ridiculous Iron [...]


  11. okay, i know i am giving this book four stars, but go read some of the reviews that give the book only one star they make excellent points critiques that are 100% valid certainly occurred to me while i was reading the book i m doling out four stars not so much because the concept behind the book blew my mind somehow, but because i think the process of thinking about the critiques i was making the same critiques as a lot of one star reviewers made was really illuminating for me like a lot of the [...]


  12. This book had such potential It actually started out interesting, with discussions between the author and her partner about ground rules, struggling to follow them, being acutely aware of how much they buy that they don t need After the first half it devolved into political rantings that had little, if anything, to do with the topic at hand While I could see a connection, however tenuous, between consumerism and the proposed cell phone tower in the tiny Vermont town where the author spends half [...]


  13. I was excited to pick this up at the library but, I had various problems with this book One, for a professional writer, I was not impressed with her skills Two, I felt she completely half a d the project New York Times which she could read at the library , coffee and 55 haircuts as essentials Give me a break And buying a whole new wardrobe for a man going into a nursing home Okay, she explained the pants and underwear even though not why it had to be new somewhat, but the rest of it Are we suppo [...]


  14. I really enjoyed this book, mostly because I felt like it was not preachy It was an experiment and the author was upfront about what was really nice and what was hard, costs and benefits I was interested in a trip into her experiment and thought that a lot of her observations were striking Without restaurants, it is hard to have a social life Her experiment was easier for being partnered At least she was not isolated alone The decision to not buy books or see movies was made much difficult by s [...]


  15. The first lesson of Not Buying It, save your money and don t buy the book How ironic that the chick who wrote Nickled and Dimed would write a cover review for this book, as it is another example of people being utterly unaware of their privileges What was it within the first month that they required 30,000 in house renovations to help them work this idea that only a truly privileged person with no kids could fathom And I am not lost on the notion that the idea is that culturally we are expected [...]


  16. I have been wanting to read this book for a few years Since I am trying to embrace a minimalist lifestyle and I love doing drastic and personal experiments I decided to finally pick this book and read it As fast as I picked it up I immediately was disappointed with what I read.The author s views are aligned with my own on so many levels and that made me have even of an attraction to reading the book But after reading the first few chapters, I found myself agreeing with so many other readers tru [...]


  17. Early on, the author recognizes the need to seek out Freud The fetish becomes pathological when the longing for the fetish passes beyond the point of being merely a necessary condition attached to the sexual object and actually takes the place of the normal aim Judith Levine goes on to say, I replace the word sexual with the word athletic sports having supplanted sex in the American erotic imagination anyway ,and yikes, I am looking at myself in the mirror The SmartWool socks became necessary to [...]


  18. The timing for this book, for me, was perfect I was in my last semester in college, terribly broke and doing an internship I was searching for camaraderie You don t understand I needed someone to tell me that it was OK that I live in NY and can t afford to buy anything That I should forfeit my feelings of shopper inadequacy, and a waning wardrobe for a purpose to prove that this material obsessed culture I m living in is toxic and based on marketing campaigns and branding, which only makes it se [...]


  19. I too could go a year without buying it if I could classify everything I want as a necessity, such as expensive coffee beans, kitty insulin, all manner of foodstuffs, and daily purchases of the NYTimes exempt anything having to do with a house remodel and anything purchased on vacation coerce and manipulate friends into taking me out to dinner, footing the bill for movies, and sending me care packagesThis woman is a hypocrite Says the arts should be funded but then never pays than a quarter to [...]


  20. I had such high hopes for this book in that it would be a fabulous experiment in actually not buying things as the title would suggest Instead it is simply a platform for a very whiny writer to complain about how hard her life is not being able to shell out for whatever she wants She is able to justify all of the necessities she continues to buy the NY Times every day, exotic rice and foods, clothes and pretty much whatever else she wants and maintains 2 households, 3 cars all for 2 people and t [...]


  21. This book was wide ranging than I expected I thought it would be a personal journey, but it looks at issues of world economics, environmental concerns and social responsibility and in this sense is enlightening, if a bit depressing at times It s a very thought provoking read, and I can t imagine that anyone who reads it will ever forget some of the lessons of the book There really is something for every consumer hereTo read the rest of this review and , please visit Trashionista


  22. I remember my mother talking about this some time back she hadn t read the book I m not sure the book had been written yet , but there had been an NPR segment or a news article about Levine s year I don t remember much other than my mother saying that Levine mentioned going to a lot of libraries and free museums and so on, but it sounded interesting, and when I ran across it at the library it struck a chord.But I am confused, and I suspect that so was Levine It s a noble, or at least well intent [...]


  23. This book has received a lot of criticism, perhaps rightly so, but I can t help feeling that some disappointed readers might be missing the point that the author s failings contribute to the richness of her analysis When she fails and when she doesn t she makes interesting and salient points about our consumer lifestyle, our country s economic structure, our nation s political choices, and her own individual feelings of elation and guilt It would be impossible and ridiculous for her to have atte [...]


  24. This book was interesting overall It made me think about my own habits There are times when the author seemed judgemental and preachy Those areas lowered my esteem for the book Another thing that decreased my enjoyment of the book was their circumstances The author and her husband seem like a wealthy couple, they have two homes in two different states and can afford to travel at their leisure Also, they work for themselves I would really like to see this experiment played out with a less wealthy [...]


  25. I have mixed feelings about this book I really support the premise, and think that what the author has done, stepped away from shopping for all but the necessities for a whole year, is fabulous It inspired the author to be mindful of her impact on the earth and on others, and to actually want less stuff However, and I guess this is what bugs me about most books of this nature, it really comes from a place of upper middle class privilege The author and her partner have three cars and two homes a [...]


  26. I admit, I fell for the hype on this one I agreed with some of her views on excessive consumption, but her over analyzing the subject of consumerism and variety of rants that veered off subject grew old very fast Her reliance on numerous quotations in order to pad out the book were off putting as well and resulted, for me, a feeling of lazy writing Maybe one of the messages the reader can take away from this book is that everyone has their priorities and one person s idea of life s necessities m [...]


  27. I really wanted to like this account of a woman and her partner who forgo all but necessary purchases for one year There were parts of this that were funny and useful, and I do think it is a good exercise to really distinguish what we need from what we want That is not as simple as it seems for most of us in the middle class But there was way too much local politics page after page about debate over a cell phone tower and not so local politics that were now both dated and tedious, not to mention [...]


  28. In this book, Judith and Paul decide not to buy anything for a year except the bare necessities I really enjoyed the book, and it made me think about what I was buying and why I also thought about what was really necessary to me I think this is something we should all be mindful of, given the eternal blast of commercials, etc telling us we need everything.


  29. Awful The only good thing about this book is that I didn t pay for it but got it from the library It s boring and badly written even though the author is a professional writer I was looking forward to some reflections and analysis but the author is about as self aware as a rock There was basically a whole chapter dedicated to the tantrum she had when she couldn t find her favourite socks Really.P.S I actually resent adding this book to my bookshelves because it was so bad but I m terrified that [...]


  30. Not Buying It by Judith Levine documents her year of living in New Hampshire and New York while buying only necessities like food She and her partner are fairly successful but importantly they learn consuming less doesn t condemn you to a life of making your own soaps And importantly, one can have a social life without surrendering your wallet to hang out Levine finds that most average Janes can and should scale back on their spending It s exciting to be a book s target audience I m generally [...]


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *